Land Acquisition Compensation in Pakistan: FCC Shuts 40 Year Old Claim, LHC Raises Multan Rate to Rs 500,000 a Marla
The FCC refused a fresh acquisition for heirs who took compensation in 1968, and LHC Multan fixed Rs 500,000 a marla for land taken for a police station.

Two courts have just ruled on land acquisition compensation in Pakistan. The Federal Constitutional Court held on 13 November 2026 that heirs of landowners who took compensation and dropped their challenge decades ago cannot force a fresh acquisition. On 16 November the Lahore High Court in Multan raised compensation for land taken for a police station to a uniform Rs 500,000 a marla.
Read together, the two rulings tell a landowner the same thing from opposite sides. Challenge an award you think is too low, and do it on time. Accept it and walk away, and the door may close for good.

The Federal Constitutional Court ruling on old acquisitions
The Federal Constitutional Court set aside a 2016 Lahore High Court order that had told the power company to start a fresh acquisition of land in Faisalabad. The original owners had received compensation in 1968 and withdrawn their references in 1970, so their heirs could not reopen it.
The case, C.A. Nos. 993 to 1010 of 2016, was decided by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Ali Baqar Najafi. It was announced in open court on 13 November 2026 and uploaded to the court's judgments page on 16 November. It concerned 236 acres in Chak No. 203-RB, Faisalabad, taken for a thermal power project.
| Date | Step in the Faisalabad acquisition |
|---|---|
| 2 July 1958 | Notification under section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 |
| 8 December 1967 | Urgency notification under section 17(4) |
| 7 October 1968 | Award announced; owners receive compensation |
| 2 April 1970 | Owners withdraw their section 18 references |
| 11 June 1991 | High Court declares the acquisition unlawful for other owners |
| 15 January 2016 | High Court orders fresh acquisition for these heirs |
| 13 November 2026 | FCC sets that order aside |
Why the heirs lost after 40 years
The court said accepting compensation, withdrawing the challenge and then waiting more than four decades all count against a landowner. A win by other landowners does not create a fresh right to sue. Each claimant must show their own case and explain the delay.
The judgment rests on three points:
- Acceptance matters. Section 31(2) of the Act says a person who took compensation without protest cannot ask for a reference under section 18.
- Delay matters. A High Court petition under Article 199 has no fixed time limit, but unexplained delay, called laches, can defeat it.
- Another owner's win is not yours. The 1991 judgment decided individual claims. It was not a judgment "in rem" that freed every plot in the notification.
The court also said the earlier ruling had ignored the 1967 urgency notification, which bore directly on whether the acquisition was lawful. A public purpose cannot save an unlawful acquisition, it noted, but a fresh acquisition cannot be ordered just because someone else got one.
The Lahore High Court Multan ruling on fair compensation
The Lahore High Court in Multan held that land acquired for a police station was undervalued. The Collector had split one plot into a road frontage and a rear part at two rates. The court said one connected plot must be valued as a whole, and fixed Rs 500,000 a marla.
The appeal, R.F.A. No. 583 of 2023, was decided by Justice Jawad Hassan and Justice Abid Hussain Chattha and announced on 16 November 2026. About 5 kanals and 7 marlas, out of a 6 kanal holding in Mouza Bouapur along Multan Khanewal Road, were taken for Police Station Seetal Mari.
| Stage | Rate set |
|---|---|
| Collector's award, 8 January 2020 | Rs 400,000 a marla for 50 feet of road frontage, Rs 250,000 for the land behind |
| Owners' claim | Rs 2.5 to 3 million a marla |
| Local Commissioner's report | Rs 1.5 to 1.8 million a marla |
| Lahore High Court, 16 November 2026 | Rs 500,000 a marla for the whole plot, plus 15% compulsory acquisition charge |

The court said neither side proved the exact market value with sale deeds. So it weighed the location, the nearby markets and showrooms, and the Local Commissioner's report together. Compensation, it said, "must not be illusory or symbolic" under Articles 23 and 24 of the Constitution.
What the two rulings mean for your land
If the government is acquiring your land, object to a low rate in writing and do not accept the money without protest. Then ask for a reference to the court in time. A landowner who takes the award quietly and waits years may lose the right to reopen it.
- Read the award and note the date you received it or learned of it.
- If the rate is too low, write "received under protest" when you take any payment.
- Apply to the Collector for a reference under section 18 within the time the Act allows.
- Collect proof of value: nearby sale deeds, earlier acquisition rates in the area, photos of the road and markets.
- Ask the referee court to value the whole plot, not a split of frontage and rear.
- If the referee court's decision is low, appeal to the High Court under section 54.
The time limits and fees for each step are set out in how to challenge a land acquisition award in Pakistan. If someone has taken your land without any acquisition at all, the remedy is different: see suing for possession under section 9.
Common questions
Can I reopen a land acquisition my grandfather accepted?
Not easily. The Federal Constitutional Court held that heirs of owners who took compensation and withdrew their references could not get a fresh acquisition more than four decades later without explaining the delay.
Does another landowner's court win help me?
Not automatically. The court said a ruling on other owners' individual claims does not create a new cause of action for you. Your own entitlement, conduct and delay must be examined separately.
Can the Collector value my plot at two rates?
The Lahore High Court in Multan said one connected plot taken for one purpose should be valued as a whole, and replaced a frontage and rear split with one rate of Rs 500,000 a marla.
What is the 15 per cent extra in land acquisition?
It is the compulsory acquisition charge under section 23(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, paid on top of the market value. In the Multan case it was kept in addition to the new rate.
Should I accept compensation if I think it is low?
If you accept it, record that you take it under protest. Section 31(2) bars a reference by anyone who took the amount without protest.
Where can I read these judgments?
The FCC ruling is on the court's judgments page, and the Multan ruling is on the Lahore High Court reported judgments page. The method is in finding a Federal Constitutional Court judgment online.
How we verified this
What we checked and where we read it.
We read both judgments in full on 17 November 2026. The FCC judgment in C.A. Nos. 993 to 1010 of 2016 (National Transmission and Despatch Company v Noor Muhammad and others) is listed on the Federal Constitutional Court judgments page with an upload date of 16 November 2026 and an open court announcement on 13 November 2026. The Lahore High Court Multan Bench judgment in R.F.A. No. 583 of 2023 is listed on the LHC reported judgments page, uploaded 16 November 2026, file 2026LHC8809. Section numbers are as quoted in the judgments.
About the author

Global Affairs & Political Economy Writer
Muhammad Hatim is a book lover who started writing because he enjoys it. At Pakistan Era he writes about international relations, geopolitics and the global economy, with a particular interest in South Asia and the forces behind current events.




