Election Recount in Pakistan: When a Candidate Can Demand One Under the 5% or 8,000 Vote Rule
Can you get a vote recount in Pakistan? Only if the margin is under 5% of votes polled or 8,000 (NA), 4,000 (PA), whichever is less. Steps and worked examples.
یہ صفحہ اردو میں پڑھیں
In Pakistan, a candidate can demand a recount from the Returning Officer only if the winning margin is under 5 per cent of the votes polled, or under 8,000 votes for a National Assembly seat (4,000 for a provincial seat), whichever is smaller. The request must be in writing and made before consolidation starts. A recount is also due if the ballots excluded from the count equal or exceed the margin.
This is Section 95(5) of the Elections Act 2017, as changed in August 2023. We read it in the ECP's own copy on 9 November 2026, with rule 86 of the Election Rules on how a recount is done. Below are the three levels where a recount can happen, a calculator in plain numbers, and how the rule applies to the NA-77 and PP-203 by-elections of 8 November.
Three officials can order a recount, at three different stages
A recount can happen at the polling station on the night, at the Returning Officer's consolidation, or on the Election Commission's own order. Only the Returning Officer stage has the 5 per cent and 8,000 vote test. Each level allows one recount only.
| Level | Who orders it | When it is allowed | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polling station | Presiding Officer | On his own motion, or on request of a candidate, election agent or polling agent present; once only | Section 90(6) |
| Constituency | Returning Officer | Written request before consolidation, if the margin test is met; once only | Section 95(5) |
| Any stage before consolidation ends | Election Commission | After notice to candidates, for reasons recorded | Section 95(6) |
| After the Gazette notification | Election tribunal | Through an election petition | Elections Act 2017, Chapter IX |
The margin test: 5 per cent or 8,000 votes, whichever is less
Work out 5 per cent of all votes polled in the constituency. Compare it with 8,000 for a National Assembly seat or 4,000 for a provincial seat. The smaller number is the line. If the winning margin is below it, the Returning Officer must recount.
- Take the total votes polled from Form-47, the provisional result.
- Multiply by 0.05 to get 5 per cent.
- Compare with 8,000 (National Assembly) or 4,000 (Provincial Assembly) and keep the smaller number.
- Subtract the runner-up's votes from the leader's votes to get the margin.
- If the margin is below the line, or the excluded ballots are equal to or more than the margin, a written request makes the recount compulsory.
Worked examples
| Seat and votes polled | 5 per cent | Fixed figure | Recount line |
|---|---|---|---|
| National Assembly, 100,000 polled | 5,000 | 8,000 | 5,000 |
| National Assembly, 200,000 polled | 10,000 | 8,000 | 8,000 |
| Provincial Assembly, 60,000 polled | 3,000 | 4,000 | 3,000 |
| Provincial Assembly, 120,000 polled | 6,000 | 4,000 | 4,000 |
In big constituencies with high turnout, the fixed 8,000 or 4,000 figure usually decides. In low turnout by-elections, the 5 per cent figure is often the smaller one, so the line is lower than people expect.
NA-77 and PP-203: neither margin qualifies for a recount on request
By our sums from the ECP's Form-47, the NA-77 margin is 13,147 votes against a line of about 4,058. The PP-203 margin is 17,602 against about 3,562. Excluded ballots are 1,135 and 721. So no candidate can demand a recount in either seat.
| Item | NA-77 Gujranwala-I | PP-203 Sahiwal-VI |
|---|---|---|
| Votes polled | 81,151 | 71,230 |
| 5 per cent | 4,057.55 | 3,561.5 |
| Fixed figure | 8,000 | 4,000 |
| Margin, leader over runner-up | 13,147 | 17,602 |
| Ballots excluded from count | 1,135 | 721 |
| Recount on request? | No | No |
The Election Commission can still order one under Section 95(6), but it had not done so when we checked. The full vote count is on our NA-77 and PP-203 result page.
How the Returning Officer runs a recount
Rule 86 of the Election Rules 2017 sets the steps. The Returning Officer serves notice of the date, time and place on every candidate, opens the polling bags in front of those present, and recounts the valid, excluded and postal ballots.
- The notice is also put up at a place where people can see it.
- Valid ballots, tendered and challenged ballots, and excluded ballots are all recounted.
- Postal ballots are recounted if needed.
- Any difference from the station results is recorded, Section 95(7).
- Consolidation must then finish within 7 days of polling for a National Assembly seat and 5 days for a provincial seat.
To check the station figures yourself before asking, compare each Form-45 with Form-47. Our guide to Forms 45, 47 and 49 shows how, and our polling agent guide explains who gets a Form-45 copy.
After the result is notified, only a tribunal can recount
Once the ECP publishes the winner in the Gazette, the Returning Officer's recount window has closed. A losing candidate who wants a recount then files an election petition before an election tribunal within 45 days.
The steps and fee are in our election petition guide.
Frequently asked questions
Can I ask for a recount of votes in Pakistan?
Yes, if you are a contesting candidate or election agent, in writing to the Returning Officer before consolidation, and only if the margin test in Section 95(5) is met.
What is the recount margin for a National Assembly seat?
Under 5 per cent of votes polled or under 8,000 votes, whichever is less. For a provincial seat the fixed figure is 4,000.
How many times can votes be recounted?
Once at the polling station by the Presiding Officer, and once by the Returning Officer. The ECP and a tribunal can also order a recount.
Can a voter ask for a recount?
No. Only a candidate, an election agent or, at the station, a polling agent present can ask. A voter can complain to the ECP.
Does a recount delay the result?
It can. Consolidation then has up to 7 days for a National Assembly seat and 5 days for a provincial seat, which pushes back the Gazette notification.
Was there a recount in NA-77?
None was posted by the ECP when we checked on 9 November 2026, and the margin of 13,147 is too large for a recount on request.
Sources and last checked
We read Sections 90(6), 95(5) to 95(7) in the ECP's copy of the Elections Act 2017, updated to 5 August 2023, and rule 86 in the ECP's Election Rules 2017, updated to 31 December 2023, on 9 November 2026. NA-77 and PP-203 figures are from the ECP's Form-47 scans; the calculations are ours. To complain to the ECP, see our ECP complaint guide.
About the author
Global Affairs & Political Economy Writer
Muhammad Hatim is a book lover who started writing because he enjoys it. At Pakistan Era he writes about international relations, geopolitics and the global economy, with a particular interest in South Asia and the forces behind current events.
