Skip to content
Pakistan Era logo
News

PPSC Could Not Cancel Selected Candidates Over the 2021 Paper Leak, Federal Constitutional Court Rules

The FCC ruled PPSC could not withdraw recommendations of Deputy Accountant and ACE Inspector candidates over the 2021 paper leak without a specific error.

Fajr Riaz, author at Pakistan EraFajr Riaz6 min read
یہ صفحہ اردو میں پڑھیں
Rows of empty wooden exam desks and chairs in a quiet hall with soft daylight

The Punjab Public Service Commission (PPSC) had no power to cancel the selection of successful candidates just because exam papers were alleged to have leaked in 2021, the Federal Constitutional Court of Pakistan has ruled. The court allowed appeals by candidates selected as Deputy Accountant and Anti-Corruption Inspector, including some who had already joined service and were then sacked. The judgment was uploaded to the court's judgments page on 19 November 2026.

For the candidates, it ends a five-year fight. They passed the written test and the interview, were recommended, and some had been drawing a salary for months. Then PPSC withdrew every recommendation in 12 categories of posts after an anti-corruption case over leaked papers. None of these candidates was named in that case.

FCC ruling: PPSC could not withdraw recommendations of selected candidates over the 2021 paper leak allegations

The FCC set aside the Lahore High Court's 2025 judgment

The Federal Constitutional Court turned the candidates' petitions into appeals, allowed them and set aside the Lahore High Court Division Bench judgment of 16 June 2025, which had upheld PPSC's withdrawal of their recommendations.

Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Ali Baqar Najafi heard the six petitions on 14 October 2026, and Justice Najafi wrote the judgment. The petitioners had been selected for Deputy Accountant (BS-16) in the Punjab Finance Department and for Inspector (BS-16) in the Anti-Corruption Establishment (ACE) Punjab.

Setting aside the 2025 judgment means the Lahore High Court single judge's ruling of 14 July 2021, which had gone in the candidates' favour, is no longer overturned.

DateWhat happened
7 December 2020PPSC recommends the ACE Inspector candidates
2 January 2021ACE Punjab registers FIR No. 1/21 over leaked exam papers
17 March 2021Full Commission decides to withdraw recommendations in 12 categories of posts
7 April 2021PPSC withdraws the recommendations
9 April 2021Appointed Deputy Accountants are terminated
14 July 2021Lahore High Court single judge rules for the candidates
16 June 2025Lahore High Court Division Bench reverses that
14 October 2026FCC allows the candidates' appeals

Regulation 63 only lets PPSC fix a specific mistake

PPSC relied on Regulation 63 of its 2016 Regulations. The court held this rule only lets the Commission review and correct an identified error in a candidate's eligibility, result or merit list. It is not a power to cancel a whole recruitment.

The rule says that if an error or omission is detected in eligibility, a result or a merit list, the recommendation based on that mistake shall be withdrawn for review and rectified. The court found that PPSC never pointed to any such error for these candidates. Their eligibility was not questioned. No entry in their results was shown to be wrong.

PPSC's own letter of 7 April 2021 said the only material received from ACE was a report about four PPSC employees. In the court's words, a corrective rule cannot be used to make candidates bear the consequences of misconduct by the Commission's own staff.

The court added that PPSC went further than the rule allows. It did not review or correct a single recommendation. It annulled the entire process and ordered fresh exams. Regulation 26, which lets PPSC cancel a candidate found short of eligibility conditions, did not apply either, since nobody's eligibility was in doubt.

What PPSC Regulation 63 and Regulation 26 allow, compared with what PPSC did in 2021

Candidates had a right to be heard first

The court held PPSC breached due process. No candidate got a notice or a chance to answer before the recommendations were withdrawn, though some lost jobs they had already joined. Article 10-A of the Constitution guarantees a fair process.

One petitioner is visually impaired, with about 10 per cent vision, and took the exam alone on a computer. His lawyer argued he could have had no link to any leak.

The government defended the sackings under section 10(1)(i) of the Punjab Civil Servants Act 1974, which allows a probationer to be terminated without notice. The court rejected that. A termination that follows a paper leak allegation carries the stigma of unfair means, it said. Such a termination needs a show-cause notice and a hearing, as the same court held earlier this year in a NUML case.

What this means for PPSC candidates now

The ruling protects candidates whose selection is cancelled for wrongdoing by others, with no error found in their own result. It does not stop PPSC from acting against anyone shown to have used unfair means.

  1. If your recommendation was withdrawn with no reason specific to you, ask PPSC in writing which error in your eligibility, result or merit position it found. Under this ruling, it must be able to name one.
  2. If you were terminated during probation after such a withdrawal, keep the termination order, the PPSC letter and your appointment letter. These are what a lawyer will need for a service appeal or writ.
  3. Cite the case correctly: CPLA No. 3264 of 2025 and connected petitions, decided by the Federal Constitutional Court on 14 October 2026.
  4. Do not ignore a show-cause notice. The court said PPSC can still act against an individual under Regulation 25 if material links that person to the leak, with notice and a hearing.

The judgment is marked not approved for reporting, so it may not appear in law reports. It still binds the parties and sets out how the court reads Regulation 63. Candidates preparing for current PPSC exams can check the PPSC passing marks and interview ratio and the public service commission jobs open now.

Paper leaks also bring penalties for candidates caught using unfair means. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa's commission, for example, publishes bans for cheating and impersonation. The FCC's point was narrower: punishment needs proof against the person, not a general doubt about the exam.

Steps for a PPSC candidate whose recommendation was withdrawn without a specific error

Common questions

Which PPSC posts were in this case?

Deputy Accountant (BS-16) in the Punjab Finance Department and Inspector (BS-16) in the Anti-Corruption Establishment Punjab. PPSC had withdrawn recommendations in 12 categories of posts in all.

Does the ruling apply to all 12 categories?

The judgment decides the six petitions before the court. Its reasoning on Regulation 63 is general, but candidates from other categories who did not appeal should take legal advice on their own position.

Were the candidates involved in the leak?

None was named in the FIR or shown to be involved. The only report ACE sent to PPSC concerned four of PPSC's own employees.

Can PPSC still take action over the leak?

Yes, against an individual if material links that person to the leak or unfair means. The court said this must follow the rules, including Regulation 25, with notice and a hearing.

Who decided the case?

Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Ali Baqar Najafi. Justice Najafi wrote the judgment. Other recent rulings, such as the one on reopening old charge sheets, also deal with due process for government employees.

How we verified this

What we checked and where we read it.

We read the full judgment in CPLA Nos. 3264, 3275 to 3277, 3300 and 3301 of 2025, against the Lahore High Court judgment of 16 June 2025 in ICA No. 13336 of 2022 and connected appeals, on 20 November 2026. It is listed on the Federal Constitutional Court judgments page with an upload date of 19 November 2026, signed at Islamabad on 14 October 2026 and marked not approved for reporting. The petitioners' names are left out on purpose. The rules quoted are from the Punjab Public Service Commission Regulations 2016 as reproduced in the judgment.

About the author

Fajr Riaz, author at Pakistan Era

Public Services and Education Journalist

Fajr Riaz

Fajr Riaz is a journalist and content writer at Pakistan Era, based in Lahore. She covers the questions people meet in everyday life in Pakistan: how a public service works, what a change in the rules means, and where to find a reliable answer.

TopicsPPSCFederal Constitutional CourtPunjabGovernment JobsService Law